By Josh Herwitt //

Phantogram with Sunday (1994), Ginger and the Peppers //
Hollywood Palladium – Los Angeles
February 28th, 2025 //

Even prior to catching Phantogram open for Kings of Leon at the always-beautiful Santa Barbara Bowl last summer (see our photos from their performance here), we knew that it wouldn’t be long before the street-beat/psych-pop duo embarked on its own proper headlining tour.

After all, Sarah Barthel (vocals, keyboards, piano, programming, synthesizers, guitars, production) and Josh Carter (vocals, guitars, programming, synthesizers, drums, percussion, production) a week earlier had just announced that their fifth LP Memory of a Day would be dropping in less than two months after unleashing “All a Mystery” and “Happy Again” as its initial two offerings.

The 12-track album arrived in October, more than four years after 2020’s Ceremony came at the height of the COVID-19 pandemic when things felt very uncertain around the world — and in many ways, they still feel very similar with an unhinged, autocratic demagogue running the free world again.

Despite having five singles issued ahead of its release after working with three-time Grammy-winning producer Andrew Dawson and the Grammy-nominated BOOTS in the studio though, Ceremony didn’t receive the same sort of fanfare as 2014’s Voices and 2016’s Three that boast some of Phantogram’s biggest hits in their catalog. While the record’s timing with the coronavirus raging out of control could have played a huge role in how it was received, you can hear Barthel and Carter chartering a different path sonically from where they started 10 years earlier on their debut full length Eyelid Movies as well.

It could be one of several reasons why at times only two songs (“Pedestal” and “Glowing”) off Ceremony made it onto the setlist during their recent “Running Through Colors” tour that spanned 28 cities across North America before a third tune (“Let Me Down”) was added back for the final three dates, culminating on a Friday night at a sold-out Hollywood Palladium with LA dream-pop act Sunday (1994) and Brazilian rockers Ginger and the Peppers serving as support.

Either way, Barthel and Carter have moved on with the spotlight squarely on their latest material now. There are moments on Memory of a Day that sonically evoke the spirit of the New York group’s early discography as Carter’s scintillating synths and bombastic beats collide with Barthel’s breathy, vibrant vocals — a recipe for success that has ultimately propelled them to pack rooms as large as the 4,000-person Palladium to the gills for more than a decade (here’s our proof in case you don’t believe us).

The hard-hitting trip-hop of “Jealousy” strikes that tone right from the onset as Barthel comes out guns blazing, leaving nothing up to interpretation with a candid inner monologue that quickly has us nodding along to her confessions of “Burning on the inside / It’s cool, I’ll kill you with a smile / Congratulations / But really ‘fuck you’ in my mind” in the opening verse. You know, because haven’t we all had some of these thoughts before?

Barthel’s lyrics have always been accessible and often relatable, but with this show being livestreamed for a modest price, she made sure to bring her “A” game for an evening that you could have unofficially labeled as “Date Night in LA: Phantogram edition” based on the sheer number of couples in attendance. The reward would be not only getting to hear Phantogram dust off gems like “Don’t Move” on their 2011 EP Nightlife and employ a full spectrum of colors to light up the stage over the course of 90 minutes, but also dig into more than half of Memory of a Day. What was somewhat curious is that Barthel and Carter didn’t perform “Running Through Colors” at any point on the tour given the name they chose — and the same could be said for the title track being skipped — yet the band did make the capacity crowd “Come Alive” via a rousing applause before exiting stage left for its brief encore break.

Since reconnecting in 2007 after returning home to the Saratoga Springs area, Barthel and Carter have turned their childhood friendship into a creative partnership that has earned them appearances at major music festivals around the world as well as unique collaborations with household names such as Big Boi and Tom Morello, the latter of which we actually covered a few weeks ago at the House of Blues down in Anaheim (read our show review here). Amidst all of the fame and fortune however, it only seems natural that a cross-country move to LA would eventually be in the cards for Phantogram considering this city’s penchant for attracting creatives and its undying love for live music.

And as much as they have fit right into their adopted hometown, Barthel and Carter know how to save their best for last when they are onstage. It’s hard to believe almost 10 years have passed since “You Don’t Get Me High Anymore” first entered our earholes, and in that span, the lead single on Three has not lost any of its staying power. In fact, we haven’t been able to stop replaying its catchy chorus in our head after being sandwiched in the middle of Phantogram’s three-song encore. That’s what any artist should hope for when it comes to telling their story, with the cream of the crop making music that can stand the test of time. Of course, only time will tell if Memory of a Day makes a lasting impression like most of their previous efforts have, and as Phantogram brought us back to the late aughts with “When I’m Small” tying a bow on the show and a six-week tour, we took a deep breath and remembered that the memory they have already left will live inside of us for more than a day but rather a lifetime.

PHANTOGRAM

Setlist:
Jealousy
Don’t Move
Fall in Love
Feedback Invisible
Pedestal
It Wasn’t Meant to Be
Mouthful of Diamonds
Run Run Blood
Attaway
You Are the Ocean
Answer
All a Mystery
Happy Again
Black Out Days
Let Me Down
Come Alive