
Manchester Orchestra
Manchester Orchestra & Thrice //
Hollywood Palladium – Los Angeles
November 13th, 2024 //
When your tour poster teases a boxing match between two seasoned bands worthy of headlining their own show in LA, the pressure is on. In one corner of the “ring” stood Southern California post-hardcore heavyweights Thrice. In the other, Atlanta’s uniquely eccentric indie rockers Manchester Orchestra. An evening of “noise and fury” was what the aforementioned promotion promised us, except the end result was anything but — for better or worse.
Thrice have taken an interesting trajectory since their formation in the late 90’s. Starting off with a fairly aggressive, post-hardcore approach early in their career, they’ve grown into a much more mature and complex sound over the years (fans have mixed opinions about this). However, performing their 2009 LP Beggars in its entirety was a unique proposition that ultimately left a lot of the crowd feeling rather underwhelmed. While we can say that the critically acclaimed album is objectively great, it’s certainly light on energy and you could tell those who showed up at the Hollywood Palladium last Wednesday were waiting for Dustin Kensrue (lead vocals, rhythm guitar, percussion), Teppei Teranishi (lead guitar, keyboards, backing vocals), Eddie Breckenridge (bass, synthesizer, backing vocals, guitars) and Riley Breckenridge (drums, percussion) to dig a bit deeper into its arsenal. Unfortunately this never occurred, as the ensuing songs were mostly deep cuts besides “Black Honey”, which surprisingly seems to have garnered quite a liking with more than 75 million listens on Spotify.

Thrice
With each co-headliner duking it out, there had to be a winner before it was all over and that winner came in the form of Manchester Orchestra undoubtedly knocking Thrice out. Celebrating the 10-year anniversary of its seminal album COPE, the five-piece — consisting of Andy Hull (lead vocals, rhythm guitar, piano), Robert McDowell (lead guitar, keyboards, backing vocals), Tim Very (drums, percussion, backing vocals), Andy Prince (bass) and touring member Brooks Tipton (piano, keyboards) — sounded triumphant as ever with Hull’s inimitable voice bellowing throughout the venue. There is simply no other act that sounds like Manchester Orchestra and you could sense the energy in the room as they took the stage. Described by one person in attendance as “emo Mumford & Sons” and in largely living up to that billing, Hull and company sailed through a lengthy, career-spanning set that made Thrice fans wish they had gotten the same.
Of course, had Thrice mixed it up a touch more and strayed further from their tepid indie rock, things might have been different in the end. But after going toe to toe for one night in the City of Angels, the winner by TKO was Manchester Orchestra.
MANCHESTER ORCHESTRA
Setlist:
Top Notch
Choose You
Girl Harbor
The Mansion
The Ocean
Every Stone
All That I Really Wanted (Acoustic)
Trees
Indentions
See It Again (with “I Can Feel Your Pain” intro)
Cope
After the Scripture
The Maze
The Gold
Bed Head
THRICE
Setlist:
All the World Is Mad
The Weight
Circles
Doublespeak
In Exile
At the Last
Wood and Wire
Talking Through Glass / We Move Like Swing Sets
The Great Exchange
Beggars
Red Telephone
Black Honey
Robot Soft Exorcism
Beyond the Pines
Photos courtesy of 















