By Josh Herwitt //

The Black Keys with The Heavy Heavy //
Greek Theatre – Los Angeles
June 3rd, 2025 //

There are certain bands over the past two decades that didn’t attain mainstream success until years after their formation.

One that always stood out is Modest Mouse with the 90’s alt-rock group not reaching radio listeners and late-night TV viewers until their fourth LP Good News for People Who Love Bad News came out in 2004 and boasted Grammy-nominated hit “Float On” despite previously releasing three excellent albums over a four-year stretch at the start.

The Black Keys are another that immediately comes to mind, considering the bluesy garage-rock duo comprised of Dan Auerbach (guitar, vocals) and Patrick Carney (drums) issued five albums in a matter of six years before cracking the Top 10 of the U.S. Billboard 200 with its 2010 breakthrough Brothers.

While the Danger Mouse-produced effort climbed as high as No. 3 on the charts here in the states, it was the Keys’ subsequent studio material — 2011’s El Camino and 2014’s Turn Blue — that saw the two-piece level up to the No. 2 and No. 1 spots, respectively. We remember being struck by the latter upon first listen (read our album review here) that ended up as one of our favorites in a crowded field that year (see our picks here).

Auberbach and Carney have put out four more albums since then, with 2019’s Let’s Rock, 2021’s Delta Kream and 2022’s Dropout Boogie landing inside the Top 10 — an impressive feat considering that one was just covers of hill country blues songs they recorded “in about 10 hours.”

Things took a turn last spring when the two childhood friends from Akron unveiled Ohio Players and had to stomach not only the mixed reviews from critics, but also the fact that it marked their first album to not make the Top 20 in 18 years. Ironically enough, lead single “Beautiful People (Stay High)” still managed to receive Grammy nominations for Best Rock Performance and Best Rock Song even if only two other songs were dropped in advance of the 14-track LP.

The charts weren’t the only indication that Ohio Players lacked the same fanfare as the Keys’ previous albums, though. That became even more apparent when the five-time Grammy winners had to cancel their North American arena tour due to poor ticket sales, yet still hard to believe for a band that in 2013 was nominated for Album of the Year. Because as Carney told Rolling Stone earlier this year after the pair fired its management: “Shit happens.”

Just how bad did it get? We will let you be the judge, but they had to forfeit almost $10 million in ticket sales and agreed to play an “America Loves Crypto” concert in their hometown for “a lot of money” as the 2024 elections loomed. If that doesn’t sound at least a tad desperate, then we might be working in the wrong business and aren’t afraid to admit it.

Auerbach and Carney, nonetheless, weren’t waiting to put last year’s turmoil behind them. A month into this year, they had already announced the first leg of their “No Rain, No Flowers” tour beginning in May and revealed the same name for the Keys’ next album a week before a string of U.S. shows scheduled at smaller, yet iconic venues such as Red Rocks Amphitheatre and Berkeley’s historic Greek Theatre.

What’s also hard to believe is that the Keys have never stepped foot onstage at LA’s own Greek Theatre in all their visits to the entertainment capital. It probably wasn’t the way they wanted to make their debut after more than two decades on the scene, but that’s how fast the band’s ascent was in the early 2010’s as it bypassed midsize rooms and went straight from headlining clubs to arenas in a couple of years.

For as much commercial success as The Black Keys have attained however, their live show lacks the same element of surprise that has made Jack White one of today’s best rock acts to catch in the flesh after witnessing him command the stage during his sold-out shows at Hollywood Palladium and Santa Barbara Bowl (read our show review here) last month in electrifying fashion. Auerbach and Carney, on the other hand, aren’t ones to switch up their setlist every night when they definitely could, although it was a pleasure to hear them dust off “Too Afraid to Love You” for the first time since 2015 in LA.

The rest of the evening went pretty much according to plan, with a cover of Canned Heat’s 1968 hit “On the Road Again” that was followed by the title track on their 13th full length coming in August. So far only two songs off No Rain, No Flowers have been revealed, including “The Night Before” that came midway through the Keys’ 90-minute affair at the Greek. What might have been more noticeable toward the end of their two-song encore was no Ohio Players material had been performed, and while that has certainly been the trend on this tour, we would venture to guess it’s not merely by coincidence. Even their recent single “Babygirl” didn’t make the cut, and we would have loved to catch personal favorites like “Just Got to Be” on 2006’s Magic Potion, “Strange Times” from 2008’s Attack & Release and “Shine a Little Light” that opens 2019’s Let’s Rock. If anything, it’s a reminder of just how expansive The Black Keys’ catalog is at this point, and as much as we enjoy hearing “Weight of Love” get its moment in the spotlight, there is something about dialing up the same setlist that feels beneath where a band of this caliber should be. That might be asking a lot of Auerbach, Carney and their cast of touring sidekicks, but as fans from their early days, we know it’s what would keep us coming back for more.

THE BLACK KEYS

Setlist:
Thickfreakness / The Breaks / I’ll Be Your Man
Your Touch
Gold on the Ceiling
Fever
Wild Child
I Got Mine
Everlasting Light
Next Girl
The Night Before
Lo/Hi
Weight of Love
Too Afraid to Love You (first time live since 2015)
Tighten Up
On the Road Again (Canned Heat cover)
No Rain, No Flowers
Heavy Soul
Howlin’ for You
She’s Long Gone

Encore:
Little Black Submarines
Lonely Boy

Editors’ Note: The entire show can be viewed here.

THE HEAVY HEAVY

Setlist:
Parakeets
Miles and Miles
Lemonade
Man of the Hills
All My Dreams
Cherry
Go Down River
Happiness
One of a Kind